Abstract
The question of whether AI substitutes or complements human work is centralto debates on the future of work. This paper examines the impact of AI on skilldemand and compensation in the U.S. economy, analysing 12 million online jobvacancies from 2018 to 2023. It investigates internal effects (within-jobsubstitution and complementation) and external effects (across occupations,industries, and regions). Our findings reveal a significant increase in demandfor AI-complementary skills, such as digital literacy, teamwork, andresilience, alongside rising wage premiums for these skills in AI roles likeData Scientist. Conversely, substitute skills, including customer service andtext review, have declined in both demand and value within AI-relatedpositions. Examining external effects, we find a notable rise in demand forcomplementary skills in non-AI roles linked to the growth of AI-related jobs inspecific industries or regions. At the same time, there is a moderate declinein non-AI roles requiring substitute skills. Overall, AI's complementary effectis up to 50% larger than its substitution effect, resulting in net positivedemand for skills. These results, replicated for the UK and Australia,highlight AI's transformative impact on workforce skill requirements. Theysuggest reskilling efforts should prioritise not only technical AI skills butalso complementary skills like ethics and digital literacy.