The increasing use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) by students in learningpresents new challenges for assessing their learning outcomes in project-basedlearning (PBL). This paper introduces a co-design study to explore thepotential of students' AI usage data as a novel material for PBL assessment. Weconducted workshops with 18 college students, encouraging them to speculate analternative world where they could freely employ AI in PBL while needing toreport this process to assess their skills and contributions. Our workshopsyielded various scenarios of students' use of AI in PBL and ways of analyzingthese uses grounded by students' vision of education goal transformation. Wealso found students with different attitudes toward AI exhibited distinctpreferences in how to analyze and understand the use of AI. Based on thesefindings, we discuss future research opportunities on student-AI interactionsand understanding AI-enhanced learning.